A complete guide to property investment in Penistone.
Last updated: 18 September 2025
Penistone offers a property market that balances affordability with steady demand, making it attractive to investors who prefer stability over volatility. With a price-to-income ratio of 4.5, buyers will find the area relatively accessible compared to many parts of Britain. The local market sees homes selling briskly, averaging 28 days on market, which speaks to decent liquidity. Owner-occupation is high, sitting in the 79th percentile, and families are overrepresented, suggesting strong demand for larger homes and long-term tenancies.
Investors should note that the median price per square foot is £250 per sq ft, and the current median asking sale price for a 3-bedroom house is £285,000, with rents for similar properties at £1,750. These factors combine to create a market where both buyers and tenants are likely to be families and couples seeking stability.
Median price per sq ft
£250 / sq ft
Average rental yield
3.7%
Capital growth (1y)
-3.7%
Sales in past year
179
* Property stats calculated for last full calendar year (2024).
Live prices in Penistone, Yorkshire and The Humber
* Extreme prices clipped for legibility
Median price
£410,000
25% of properties below...
£282,500
75% of properties below...
£527,500
Most expensive property
£1,780,000
Live listings
83
Median days on market
28
Penistone’s property market is likely to remain steady, with families and couples continuing to drive demand for larger homes. The annualised growth over three years of 3.2% suggests the area has delivered reasonable returns for patient investors, although the 1-year capital growth of -3.7% serves as a reminder that the market is not immune to short-term fluctuations.
Liquidity should stay healthy, given the average days on market of 28 days and a decent volume of 179 annual sales. With affordability metrics such as the price-to-income ratio of 4.5 and rent-to-income ratio of 16.7%, the area is likely to remain attractive to both buyers and renters. Investors who focus on family homes and are willing to play the long game should find Penistone a reliable, if unspectacular, addition to their portfolio.
Average yield (%)
* 2025 data for YTD
Median price per sq ft (£/sq ft)
* 2025 data for YTD
Investment properties in Penistone, Yorkshire and The Humber
£185,000 - Offers in Region of
3 bedroom semi-detached house for sale
Church View Crescent, Penistone
£360,000
3 bedroom detached house for sale
Wellhouse Lane, Penistone, Barnsl...
£199,950 - Offers Over
2 bedroom semi-detached house for sale
Park Avenue, Penistone, Sheffield, ...
£200,000 - Offers Over
3 bedroom semi-detached house for sale
Clarel Street, Penistone, Sheffield...
Buyers have some negotiation leverage, but not much.
• Median discount: £3,000
• 1 in 4 properties sell at > £5,000 below asking
• 1 in 10 properties sell at > £10,000 below asking
In percentage terms:
• Median discount of 1.5%
• 25% of properties discounted by > 2.2%
• 10% of properties discounted by > 4.6%
Top postcodes for rental yield and (annualised) capital growth
GeoGlider calculates property investment stats by blending official and proprietary datasets. Here's a quick overview of key sources and how we use them:
HM Land Registry: Property transaction and sold-price records for England & Wales used to calculate historical capital growth, price levels and comparables.
Office for National Statistics (ONS): Demographic and economic indicators for the UK, including Census 2021, supporting area profiling and market context.
Ordnance Survey: Authoritative UK geospatial data powering accurate boundaries, roads and terrain for mapping and spatial analysis.
GeoProp: Our proprietary AI pipeline that processes millions of property listings to extract rich features and live market signals.
Department for Levelling Up, Housing & Communities: Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) scores and property floor areas.
HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC): Household income and employment data to understand local affordability and economic conditions.
Data is updated continuously, matched across sources and rigorously validated.